Originally
Released: June 2001
Found on: Amnesiac
This song premiered during the Kid A tour 2000 and was a crowd favorite.
It featured Thom sitting at piano and Colin playing an upright bass.
Towards the end of the song, the full band comes in and the song really
takes off. The version that was played at the Sundance Festival is
indeed the studio version that will appear on Amnesiac.
From Jam!: Here's a novelty: guitars! Yorke's voice is pushed way
up front, and the track begins with him loudly inhaling. The full
band gradually joins the mix, and it all ends with an almost gospelly,
piano-led denouement. The lyrics, which seem to taunt authority into
cracking down on the rabble, could have been given a completely different
meaning had they been set to more triumphant music. (You can practically
hear Bono delivering a song like this without a shred of irony). But
here, Yorke sounds defeated, as if even he's not confident that an
insurgency would succeed.
Review from SXSW by Allstar: "You and Whose Army?" slightly recalled
OK Computer in that Yorke's yearning vocal cry of "Come on, Come on,
Come on…" repeated over and over somehow felt a tad like "Karma Police."
A crunching organ and string section drives the track, which falls
under lilting and poetic. |
|